Nyaa.si is widely considered the most critical source for anime content globally. Because most anime fansub groups and encoders upload there first, it offers the highest "retention" and variety of releases.
Indexers unavailable due to failures: Nyaa - sonarr :: forums
However, using Nyaa directly in Sonarr can be tricky due to Cloudflare protection and specific search parameter requirements. To bypass these hurdles, most users utilize a "manager" like Prowlarr or Jackett . Step-by-Step Setup: Linking Nyaa to Sonarr